Skip to main content
Facilitate Magazine: Informing Workplace and Facilities Management Professionals - return to the homepage Facilitate magazine logo
  • Search
  • Visit Facilitate Magazine on Facebook
  • Visit Facilitate Magazine on LinkedIn
  • Visit @Facilitate_Mag on Twitter
Visit the website of the Institute of Workplace and Facilities Management Logo of the Institute of Workplace and Facilities Management

Main navigation

  • Home
  • News
    • Comment
    • People
    • Reports
    • Research
  • Features
    • Analysis
    • Features
    • Round Tables
    • Webinars
  • Outsourcing
    • Contracts
    • FM Business Models
    • Interviews
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Opinion
    • Procurement
    • Trends
  • Know-How
    • Explainers
    • Legal Updates
    • White Papers
  • Jobs
  • Topics
    • Workplace Services
      • Hospitality
      • Catering
      • Cleaning
      • Front of House
      • Grounds Maintenance
      • Helpdesk
      • Mailroom
      • Manned Guarding / Security
      • Pest Control
      • Washroom Services
      • Disaster Recovery
      • Specialist Services
    • Professional Performance
      • Behavioural Change
      • Continual Professional Development
      • Education
      • Management
      • Recruitment
      • Training
    • Workplace Performance
      • Benchmarking
      • Health & Wellbeing
      • Operational Readiness
      • Procurement
      • Security
      • Workplace User Experience
      • Workplace Culture
    • Compliance
      • Health & Safety
      • Risk & Business Continuity
      • Standards
      • Statutory Compliance
    • Building Services
      • Architecture & Construction
      • Asset Management
      • Building Controls
      • Building Fabric
      • Drinking Water
      • Fire Protection
      • HVAC
      • Landscaping
      • Mechanical & Electrical
      • Building Security
      • Water, Drainage & Plumbing
    • Technology
      • Building Information Modelling
      • CAFM
      • Data & Networks
      • Document Management
      • Information Management
      • Internet of Things (IoT)
      • Software & Systems
    • Energy management
      • Energy Management Systems
      • Electricity
      • Gas
      • Solar
      • Wind
    • Sustainability
      • Environmental Quality
      • Social Value
      • Waste Management
      • Recycling
    • Workspace Design
      • Agile Working
      • Fit-Out & Refurbishment
      • Inclusive Access
      • Lighting
      • Office Interiors
      • Signage
      • Space Planning
      • Storage
      • Vehicle Management / Parking
      • Washroom
    • Sectors
      • Corporate Office
      • Education
      • Healthcare
      • Manufacturing
      • International
      • Retail
      • Sports & Leisure
      • Regions
  • Buyers' Guide
Quick links:
  • Home
  • Topics
Know How
Content
Legal Updates
Workplace services
Compliance
Sustainability
Topics
Know How
Content
Legal Updates
Workplace services
Compliance
Sustainability

The catch R22 situation

Open-access content 20th August 2008

It was back in 2000 that an EU directive on the phaseout of HCFC refrigerants was passed. However, it's only now that  the real impact of the controls is likely to be felt

 

by Andrew Keogh

 

12 January 2007

 

It has not been possible to purchase new air conditioning equipment that uses the HCFC refrigerants R22 since the end of 2003. Nevertheless an unknown, large number of existing air conditioning systems that use R22 are still in situ throughout the UK. The EU directive that mandated the phaseout of HCFC refrigerants was passed in 2000. One could be forgiven for assuming that, in 2007,  its purpose had been fulfilled by now. However, the real impact of the directive is likely to be felt only in the coming few years. Hundreds of thousands of units installed on thousands of buildings all still require supplies of R22 for service and maintenance.
As well as prohibiting HCFC  in new products, the directive also set a timetable for the eventual phaseout of R22 for servicing existing plant. To meet the requirements of the legislation, the quantity of R22 available will steadily reduce up to 2010.

 

Handling the change


So how should those responsible for the operation of building systems plan to handle these changes? The first step has to be to assess the magnitude of the task. This requires a thorough survey of the building's systems to determine what plant uses R22 - its age, state of repair, maintenance and reliability history, and the impact a possible failure might have on the business of the building's occupants.
The second step is to develop a plan for the plant's eventual replacement. For much of the installed base this will be a relatively straightforward decision as the equipment in question is probably already 10-15 years old. By the time the restriction on the use of new R22 takes effect this plant will be nearing the end of its anticipated economic life and can be replaced with a non-HCFC alternative. While no one likes spending money on something that has probably been taken for granted for the past 15 years, there are substantial potential benefits to be derived from the situation. New equipment is considerably more energy efficient than its predecessors and offers significant savings in running costs. It is also likely to be smaller, lighter and less noisy.

 

The alternatives


In most cases like-for-like replacement of plant cannot be advocated. It is highly likely that the building configuration, occupancy and usage patterns will have changed dramatically since the current equipment was installed. Step three in the replacement process should be a thorough review of operational demands to ensure that any new plant is appropriate to current and future needs and thus offers the maximum possible energy efficiency.
For those R22 units that will still have significant economic life left come 2010, it may though be prudent to plan to convert them to an alternative refrigerant sometime shortly thereafter. There are two principal alternative refrigerants: R407C and R417A. R407C is definitely not a drop-in, while R417A is claimed to be so.


Refrigerant choice has become much clearer in recent years and there are essentially two broad alternatives: an HFC such as R410A or R134A or 'natural' gases such as ammonia or propane. None offers a perfect solution so it's a question of compromise.


Ammonia has some excellent environmental credentials as it has no direct global warming potential (GWP). It has been extensively used for many years in industrial refrigeration, food processing and breweries. However, ammonia is highly toxic, concentrations of 0.5 per cent v/v can be rapidly fatal. It is also flammable at concentrations of between 15 to 28 per cent (v/v) in air. While the highly noxious smell of ammonia aids leak detection its extreme unpleasantness can also induce panic.


Propane also offers excellent environmental credentials as it has no direct GWP. Hydrocarbons have previously only been used in large industrial refrigeration systems and, more recently, in domestic refrigerators. However, such hydrocarbons have one principal disadvantage, their flammability/explosiveness (1 kg of hydrocarbon has the same explosive potential as 1 kg of TNT). The European standard EN378 already imposes limits on the use of ammonia and hydrocarbons in some types of buildings and systems.

 

HFCs


Neither toxic nor flammable and as such there are very few limitations on the use of HFCs. However, if released into the atmosphere HFCs will contribute directly to global warming but today's systems are designed to ensure this never happens. And any impact on global warming is small compared to the release of CO2 during the production of the electricity required to run the plant, whatever the refrigerant used.
The magnitude of this indirect effect is determined by the energy efficiency of the plant and this tends to be broadly similar today for all refrigerant types. For these reasons, the best overall compromise is offered by the current HFC refrigerants.

 

Andrew Keogh is engineering
manager at Carrier Air Conditioning

 

Share
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linked in
  • Mail
  • Print

Most-Popular

 

Latest Jobs

Catering Team Leader/Manager

North West England
Excellent career prospects
Reference
54267

Estates Officer - Maintenance Electrician

London
£25.39 per hour
Reference
54266

Assistant Development Manager – Student Accommodation – Client Side

Manchester
£45 - 50k plus 12.5% bonus potential, 8% pension.
Reference
54256
See all jobs »

 

 

Sign up to our newsletter

News, jobs and updates

Sign up

Subscribe to print

Sign up to receive our weekly Redactive News e-newsletter.

Subscribe
Facilitate magazine cover, June 2020
​
FOLLOW US
@Facilitate_Mag
Facilitate Magazine
Facilitate Magazine
CONTACT US
Contact us
Tel: 020 7880 6200
​

IWFM

About IWFM
Become a member
Qualifications
Events

Information

Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Cookie Policy
Think Green

Get in touch

Contact us
Advertise with us
Subscribe to Facilitate Magazine
Write for Facilitate Magazine

General

IWFM Jobs
Help

www.facilitatemagazine.com and Facilitate magazine are published by Redactive Media Group. All rights reserved. Reproduction of any part is not allowed without written permission.

Redactive, Level 5, 78 Chamber Street, London, E1 8BL