Skip to main content
Facilitate Magazine: Informing Workplace and Facilities Management Professionals - return to the homepage Facilitate magazine logo
  • Search
  • Visit Facilitate Magazine on Facebook
  • Visit Facilitate Magazine on LinkedIn
  • Visit @Facilitate_Mag on Twitter
Visit the website of the Institute of Workplace and Facilities Management Logo of the Institute of Workplace and Facilities Management

Main navigation

  • Home
  • News
    • Comment
    • People
    • Reports
    • Research
  • Features
    • Analysis
    • Features
    • Round Tables
    • Webinars
  • Outsourcing
    • Contracts
    • FM Business Models
    • Interviews
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Opinion
    • Procurement
    • Trends
  • Know-How
    • Explainers
    • Legal Updates
    • White Papers
  • Jobs
  • Topics
    • Workplace Services
      • Hospitality
      • Catering
      • Cleaning
      • Front of House
      • Grounds Maintenance
      • Helpdesk
      • Mailroom
      • Manned Guarding / Security
      • Pest Control
      • Washroom Services
      • Disaster Recovery
      • Specialist Services
    • Professional Performance
      • Behavioural Change
      • Continual Professional Development
      • Education
      • Management
      • Recruitment
      • Training
    • Workplace Performance
      • Benchmarking
      • Health & Wellbeing
      • Operational Readiness
      • Procurement
      • Security
      • Workplace User Experience
      • Workplace Culture
    • Compliance
      • Health & Safety
      • Risk & Business Continuity
      • Standards
      • Statutory Compliance
    • Building Services
      • Architecture & Construction
      • Asset Management
      • Building Controls
      • Building Fabric
      • Drinking Water
      • Fire Protection
      • HVAC
      • Landscaping
      • Mechanical & Electrical
      • Building Security
      • Water, Drainage & Plumbing
    • Technology
      • Building Information Modelling
      • CAFM
      • Data & Networks
      • Document Management
      • Information Management
      • Internet of Things (IoT)
      • Software & Systems
    • Energy management
      • Energy Management Systems
      • Electricity
      • Gas
      • Solar
      • Wind
    • Sustainability
      • Environmental Quality
      • Social Value
      • Waste Management
      • Recycling
    • Workspace Design
      • Agile Working
      • Fit-Out & Refurbishment
      • Inclusive Access
      • Lighting
      • Office Interiors
      • Signage
      • Space Planning
      • Storage
      • Vehicle Management / Parking
      • Washroom
    • Sectors
      • Corporate Office
      • Education
      • Healthcare
      • Manufacturing
      • International
      • Retail
      • Sports & Leisure
      • Regions
  • Buyers' Guide
Quick links:
  • Home
  • Topics
Know How
Content
Legal Updates
Compliance
Health & Safety
Topics
Know How
Content
Legal Updates
Compliance
Health & Safety

Vital accountability

Open-access content 22nd August 2008

Despite widespread criticism, the Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Bill is likely to become law in 2007.  But will it lead to a reduction in workplace fatalities?

 

by Sarah Lamont with Duncan Astill

 

01 December 2006

 

The courts are littered with failed corporate manslaughter charges. This is because the prosecution needs to establish, not only the personal guilt of a senior manager, but of one who is also the embodiment (or directing mind) of the organisation before the organisation itself is guilty of manslaughter. When faced with complex organisations where specific duties are often delegated downwards, individual fault may not lie with the appropriate person (if indeed there is such an individual).

 

However, even where manslaughter charges don't stick, companies are regularly prosecuted under Health and Safety legislation for deaths in the workplace. Fines are continuing
to rise (Transco received a record
£15 million fine in 2005) so why do we need manslaughter charges?
The answer lies in the health and safety 'brand image'. In the eyes of the public, health and safety is often considered to be a regulatory breach, not criminal; a health and safety conviction does not send out the same message as one of corporate manslaughter.

 

The new offence

 

Although changes may be coming the offence is set out in the draft bill as:

 

"An organisation … is guilty of an offence if the way in which any of its activities are managed or organised by its senior managers caused a person's death and amounts to a gross breach of a … duty of care owed ….".

 

A "senior manager" is defined as someone who plays a significant role in the making of decisions about how the organisation or a substantial part of its activities are managed or organised, or someone who actually managed and organises the company. The offence itself goes on to refer to the breach of duty as "gross".

 

This is where the conduct of the organisation falls far below what can reasonably be expected of the organisation in the circumstances.

 

In considering this question the jury is asked to consider whether the company complied with health and safety legislation. Interestingly, this includes the extent to which the attitudes or practices that were likely to have encouraged the alleged offence, raising the possibility of evidence concerning unrelated practices being used to demonstrate a wilful disregard.

 

The government is at pains to point out that the intention is to reserve the new offence for cases of gross negligence: the most serious cases, where criminal sanction is appropriate.

 

No personal liability

 

An individual cannot be guilty of aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring an offence of corporate manslaughter. They can of course continue to face charges under the existing common law offence in respect of their own personal conduct and can be prosecuted individually under health and safety legislation. However, the critics say that without the individuals who hide behind the corporate veil being brought to account, there will continue to be an incentive to cut corners, save money and cost lives. The TGWU and the construction union Ucatt are running a campaign to make company directors "take the workplace health record of their company as seriously as its financial one". This appears to be having some momentum with the HSC having asked its civil servants earlier this year to "explore the possibility of imposing duties on directors" of private sector and public bodies.

 

Reputation

 

The alternative view is that companies spend millions of pounds on marketing an image to consumers and that a manslaughter charge will cost far more in the marketplace than they will ever have to pay in fines. It is perhaps fair to say that any company convicted of corporate manslaughter, especially in the early days of the offence, is likely to cause reputational damage, but, then again, it is often investor confidence that remains crucial and a rebrand can be swiftly achieved.

 

Act now

 

Despite taking almost a decade to arrive, this bill seems certain to make it into law in one form or another. FMs should be strengthening their approach to heath and safety, making sure that this is led from the top and that proper compliance measures are in place. This will reduce the risk of a workplace fatality and at the same time reduce the risk of a manslaughter prosecution.

 

Sarah Lamont and Duncan Astill are partners at Bevan Brittan

 

FM QUICK FACTS

 

  • Every month, six-figure fines are handed out to companies whose employees have died while at work because of management failings

  • One retail giant received fines totalling £550,000 following its conviction under the Health and Safety at Work Act following the death of a customer

 

Share
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linked in
  • Mail
  • Print

Most-Popular

 

Latest Jobs

Property Programme Manager - Fire Safety – Student Accommodation (MC)

London (Central)
£100k plus bonus + package
Reference
54310

Interim Head of Health & Safety

London (Central)
£300 per day (PAYE)
Reference
54307

Engineering Manager

Staffordshire
£60,000 + car +bens
Reference
54209
See all jobs »

 

 

Sign up to our newsletter

News, jobs and updates

Sign up

Subscribe to print

Sign up to receive our bi-monthly magazine

Subscribe
Facilitate magazine cover, June 2020
​
FOLLOW US
@Facilitate_Mag
Facilitate Magazine
Facilitate Magazine
CONTACT US
Contact us
Tel: 020 7880 6200
​

IWFM

About IWFM
Become a member
Qualifications
Events

Information

Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Cookie Policy
Think Green

Get in touch

Contact us
Advertise with us
Subscribe to Facilitate Magazine
Write for Facilitate Magazine

General

IWFM Jobs
Help

www.facilitatemagazine.com and Facilitate magazine are published by Redactive Media Group. All rights reserved. Reproduction of any part is not allowed without written permission.

Redactive, Level 5, 78 Chamber Street, London, E1 8BL