Skip to main content
Facilitate Magazine: Informing Workplace and Facilities Management Professionals - return to the homepage Facilitate magazine logo
  • Search
  • Visit Facilitate Magazine on Facebook
  • Visit Facilitate Magazine on LinkedIn
  • Visit @Facilitate_Mag on Twitter
Visit the website of the Institute of Workplace and Facilities Management Logo of the Institute of Workplace and Facilities Management

Main navigation

  • Home
  • News
    • Comment
    • People
    • Reports
    • Research
  • Features
    • Analysis
    • Features
    • Round Tables
    • Webinars
  • Outsourcing
    • Contract Finder
    • Contracts
    • FM Business Models
    • Interviews
    • Mergers & Acquisitions
    • Opinion
    • Procurement
    • Trends
  • Know-How
    • Explainers
    • Legal Updates
    • White Papers
  • Jobs
  • Topics
    • Workplace Services
      • Hospitality
      • Catering
      • Cleaning
      • Front of House
      • Grounds Maintenance
      • Helpdesk
      • Mailroom
      • Manned Guarding / Security
      • Pest Control
      • Washroom Services
      • Disaster Recovery
      • Specialist Services
    • Professional Performance
      • Behavioural Change
      • Continual Professional Development
      • Education
      • Management
      • Recruitment
      • Training
    • Workplace Performance
      • Benchmarking
      • Health & Wellbeing
      • Operational Readiness
      • Procurement
      • Security
      • Workplace User Experience
      • Workplace Culture
    • Compliance
      • Health & Safety
      • Risk & Business Continuity
      • Standards
      • Statutory Compliance
    • Building Services
      • Architecture & Construction
      • Asset Management
      • Building Controls
      • Building Fabric
      • Drinking Water
      • Fire Protection
      • HVAC
      • Landscaping
      • Mechanical & Electrical
      • Building Security
      • Water, Drainage & Plumbing
    • Technology
      • Building Information Modelling
      • CAFM
      • Data & Networks
      • Document Management
      • Information Management
      • Internet of Things (IoT)
      • Software & Systems
    • Energy management
      • Energy Management Systems
      • Electricity
      • Gas
      • Solar
      • Wind
    • Sustainability
      • Environmental Quality
      • Social Value
      • Waste Management
      • Recycling
    • Workspace Design
      • Agile Working
      • Fit-Out & Refurbishment
      • Inclusive Access
      • Lighting
      • Office Interiors
      • Signage
      • Space Planning
      • Storage
      • Vehicle Management / Parking
      • Washroom
    • Sectors
      • Corporate Office
      • Education
      • Healthcare
      • Manufacturing
      • International
      • Retail
      • Sports & Leisure
      • Regions
  • Buyers' Guide
Quick links:
  • Home
  • Topics
Know How
Legal Updates
Compliance
Sustainability

Court Report: Nuisance and fire

Open-access content Friday 8th February 2013 — updated 1.53pm, Tuesday 5th May 2020
Matthew Stanton reports on a case of liability for damage caused to a neighbour's land.

8 February 2013

The issue
For a person to be liable for damage caused to a neighbour's land, there normally has to be negligence on their part that caused the damage.

However, the rule in Rylands v Fletcher (1868) provides that a defendant is liable for damage done to neighbouring land if: (i) the defendant brought on to his land something that is dangerous; (ii) the danger escaped from the defendant's land to the claimant's land; and (iii) the use to which the defendant had put his land was 'non-natural'.

As no negligence is required on the part of the defendant, liability is strict.

"Non-natural" has been interpreted by the courts to mean something that is an extraordinary use of the land.

In the case of Stannard v Gore the court looked at the question of 'non-natural use' and whether Rylands v Fletcher applies where the dangerous 'thing' that escaped the land was fire.


Decision

Gore's claim for negligence failed at first instance as the court found that Stannard had a defence under the Fires Prevention (Metropolis) Act 1774 because the fire was accidental and spread through no fault of Stannard's.

However, the court found that the haphazard way in which the tyres were stored amounted to a non-natural use of the land.

According to expert evidence, while tyres in their normal state are not flammable, once a primary fire has developed, it can produce sufficient heat to ignite tyres, which can spread to neighbouring tyres rapidly and is difficult to put out.

The court concluded that tyres are "dangerous" and as their storage meant the use of the land was non-natural and the fire escaped, all of the requirements of Rylands v Fletcher had been satisfied. As liability under Rylands v Fletcher is strict, this meant that Stannard was liable notwithstanding the absence of negligence.

Response

Stannard successfully argued that the County Court had erred in its application of Rylands v Fletcher to fire cases.

The Court of Appeal found that: (i) tyres, as such, are not exceptionally dangerous; (ii) the tyres did not escape, what escaped was the fire; and (iii) keeping a stock of tyres on the premises of a tyre-fitting business was not an extraordinary, unusual or non-natural use of the land. Strict liability under Rylands v Fletcher was therefore not established.

The court noted that fire damage cases are likely to be very difficult to bring within Rylands v Fletcher because it is the 'thing' brought on to the land that must escape, not the fire that was started or increased by the 'thing'.

Liability for fire damage under the rule may be limited to cases where the fire has been deliberately or negligently started and, in any event, starting a fire on one's land may be an ordinary use of the land.

Conclusion

  • The courts' increasingly restrictive approach to the rule in Rylands v Fletcher, limiting it to the rare instances of isolated escapes, led to Lord Hoffman saying in Transco v Stockport MDC [2004]: "It is hard to escape the conclusion that the intellectual effort devoted to the rule by judges and writers over many years has brought forth a mouse."
  • It is improbable now that someone can ever be liable under Rylands v Fletcher for damage caused by fire originating on their premises, unless the fire was started deliberately, such as where fire or sparks are an essential part of the dangerous thing kept on the defendant's land.
  • Even though liability for fire damage is unlikely to be established under Rylands v Fletcher, a landowner could still be liable for damage to neighbouring property caused by fire escaping their land if negligence on their part can be established.
  • However, despite its limited use, the rule still exists so landowners should be cautious that their activities and things stored on their land are not likely to do damage to neighbouring property. A note of caution from the Court of Appeal: "Make sure you have insurance cover for losses occasioned by fire on your premises."

Matthew Stanton is an associate in Allen & Overy LLP's real estate litigation team



Also filed in:
Topics
Know How
Content
Legal Updates
Compliance
Sustainability

You might also like...

Share
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Linked in
  • Mail
  • Print

Today's top reads

 

Latest Jobs

Project Leader (Maternity Cover One Year Contract)

Cambridge
Circa £50,000 Pro Rata + Benefits & Opportunities
Reference
56378

Maintenance Supervisor

Surrey
Up to £43,000 + Excellent Package & Opportunities
Reference
56376

Regional Facilities Manager

South West England
Circa £40,000 + Benefits & Opportunities
Reference
56375
See all jobs »

 

 

Sign up to our newsletter

News, jobs and updates

Sign up

Subscribe to print

Sign up to receive our bi-monthly magazine

Subscribe
Facilitate magazine cover, June 2020
​
FOLLOW US
@Facilitate_Mag
Facilitate Magazine
Facilitate Magazine
CONTACT US
Contact us
Tel: 020 7880 6200
​

IWFM

About IWFM
Become a member
Qualifications
Events

Information

Privacy Policy
Terms & Conditions
Cookie Policy
Think Green

Get in touch

Contact us
Advertise with us
Subscribe to Facilitate Magazine
Write for Facilitate Magazine

General

IWFM Jobs
Help

© 2022 • www.facilitatemagazine.com and Facilitate Magazine are published by Redactive Media Group. All rights reserved. Reproduction of any part is not allowed without written permission.

Redactive Media Group Ltd, 71-75 Shelton Street, London WC2H 9JQ